I was arrested recently by Paul's claim to have incredibly deep feelings for the Jews (Rom 9:1). Although I've read the passage before, the Spirit would not leave me alone about this passage. As a result of my meditation, I organized a lesson that I taught twice this past weekend. I left the last 10-15 minutes open for discussion that really helped me along in my thinking. The result of my meditation and the contributions of the classes I taught are below:
I. Paul's emotional response to lost Jews
A. Paul's claim is really pretty remarkable. He claims that he felt great sorrow or heaviness such as the sorrow one might feel when he learns that a close friend is moving far away (Jn 16.6), when a woman approaches labor (Jn 16.21), when a person is excluded from a community he desires to be included in (2 Cor 2:7), and when a person learns of the death of a loved one (Philippians 2:27). As I meditated on this claim, I realized how appropriate the KJV's "heaviness" is as a translation. Paul is saying that he has a great big cloud hanging over him. And that cloud is an emotional pain. Paul also claims that he is continually feeling agony emotionally. The same word is used in Luke 16 to describe the pain of the wealthy man who woke up in hell. So, to summarize, Paul has a continual sense of emotional pain and agony over the lost state of the Jews.
B. Paul recognizes that this claim is difficult to believe. That is why he starts off with a three-fold affirmation of the truthfulness of his claims. He says that he speaks the truth in Christ, he is not lying, and the Holy Spirit actually bears witness with his conscience. So I am left with no choice but to believe that Paul is describing his actual feeling.
C. Paul spells out what kind of attitude grows out of this deep feeling of sorrow and agony: self-sacrifice. And not just the desire to lose sleep and undergo discomfort for the sake of the lost. Paul actually has the attitude that he is willing to forego the bliss of eternity with God so that the Jews could enjoy that bliss.
II. Paul's lifestyle backs up his claims with a life of sacrifice.
To some extent, I am a product of the enlightenment. So I tend to be skeptical. I can just imagine that if I claimed to feel this type of deep sorrow and continual emotional pain for a people, some would say "prove it." So I looked in Acts to see if Paul's lifestyle matched his claims. This is what I found:
Passage | Activity | Result |
Acts 9:20, 23 | Proclaimed in the synagogues in Damascus | Plot to kill him; he escapes to Jerusalem |
Acts 9:29 | Preached, disputed with Greek speaking Jews in Jerusalem | Plot to kill him; he escapes to Tarsus |
Acts 13:5 | Preached in synagogue in Salamis | |
Acts 13:14, 45, 50 | Spoke in synagogue in Antioch in Pisidia | Contradicted, reviled, persecuted, driven away |
Acts 14:1, 2, 5 | Spoke in synagogue in Iconium | Stirred up and poisoned Gentiles, attempt to mistreat and stone |
Acts 14:19 | In Lystra | Stoned Paul to pt of death |
Acts 16:3 | Circumcised Timothy for Jews’ sake | |
Acts 16:13 | Preached on Sabbath in Philippi | Attacked and imprisoned |
Acts 17:1-3, 5 | Reasoned in synagogue in Thessalonica | Jealousy; mob, riot, attack |
Acts 17:10, 13 | Gave word in synagogue in Berea | Agitation and riot |
Acts 17:17 | Reasoned in synagogue in Athens | |
Acts 18:4, 6, 9-10, 12 | Reasoned in synagogue in Corinth | Opposed, reviled, threatened, sued |
Acts 18:19 | Reasoned in synagogue in Ephesus | |
Acts 19:8-9 | Reasoned in synagogue in Ephesus | Spoke evil of the way |
Acts 20:3 | | Plot made by Jews in Greece |
Acts 21:26, 30-32 | Paul purifies self and pays for other’s vows for Jew’s sake | Seized, dragged, almost killed, beaten |
Acts 23:1, 10 | Spoke to council of Jewish leaders | Violence that threatened to tear Paul apart |
Acts 28:17, 23 | Calls together local leaders of Jews in Rome teaching morning till night | Some believed and some did not. |
When I look at these passages, I see that I cannot gainsay what Paul claimed. I mean, how many times do you have to get beaten and driven away by the Jews before you think, "Perhaps this isn't the best method?" What made him go back again and again? It was his love for the Jews. It was this deep, emotional, sorrow and pain he felt for the Jews.
As I look at this passage and think it through, I see three concrete aspects of Paul's life that grow out of his feelings:
1. Prayer. His feelings provoked him to pray (Rom 10:1).
2. Proactive evangelism. The chart above shows that Paul pursued the Jews. When he arrived in a town, he sought out the synagogue. He did not have a GPS or the yellow pages. He had to find them. In Acts 16, we read that he found the Jews and God-fearers praying at the river on the Sabbath. How did he know they would be there? He found out where the Jews met, joined them, and spoke up about the gospel.
3. Persistence in the face of rejection. Paul never stopped going after the Jews. Even after we've read of time after time of Paul's being kicked out, reviled, beaten, and even stoned, we find that Paul's first act after arriving in Rome is to call the local Jewish leaders to him to reason with them from morning to evening for the gospel's sake. Real sorrow of heart grows into persistence.
III. Application
I am forced to confess that my life does not match up with Paul's. I am likewise forced to admit that my emotions do not either. Why not? The following reasons are the ones that I and others thought of:
1. Self-focus: all I care about is what is going on with me, my family, my church, etc.
2. Self-righteousness: I am actually irritated and frustrated by the ungodly because I think so highly of myself
3. Self-dependence: Paul's tenacity and persistence grew out of his dependence upon God. In my experience, it takes only a few rejections (pretty mild when compared to Paul's) to make me timid.
4. Isolation from the lost. This can be physical isolation that grows out of spending all of our discretionary time with other believers, all of our discretionary time as a family, etc.
5. Thoughtlessness. These deep emotions aren't the result of five minutes of meditation and prayer. They grow out of prolonged, regular meditation on truth.